What is a Preservation Deposition? The Ultimate Guide for Attorneys

More than ever, attorneys need to stay on top of evolving strategies for managing evidence, especially when it comes to preserving critical information. One tool that’s often overlooked but can be a game changer in ensuring that vital testimony is available when needed is the preservation deposition. If you’ve been hearing the term “preservation deposition” and wondering what exactly it means, you’re in the right place. Let’s break it down and explore how this can benefit you in your legal practice.

So What is a Preservation Deposition?

A preservation deposition is a type of legal deposition used to capture and preserve the testimony of a witness or expert before a trial. This method is especially useful when there’s concern that the witness may not be available or their testimony may be compromised as the case progresses. It allows you to preserve a record of their statements under oath, ensuring that their testimony can be presented at trial if they become unavailable later on.

The key difference between a preservation deposition and a traditional deposition is its purpose. While a traditional deposition is usually conducted to gather evidence or prepare for a case, a preservation deposition’s primary goal is to safeguard testimony for future use. This is commonly used in situations where there’s a risk that the witness might not be able to testify due to illness, death, or other unpredictable circumstances.

Why is a Preservation Deposition Important?

Preserving testimony through depositions is critical for a few key reasons:

1. Witness Availability: There are cases where a crucial witness may be elderly, ill, or otherwise at risk of being unavailable before trial. By using a preservation deposition, you ensure that their testimony is on record and can be utilized later.
2. Preventing Witness Tampering: A preservation deposition can also serve as a safeguard against the possibility of a witness being influenced or coerced before they testify in court.
3. Preserving Memory: People forget things over time. A preservation deposition helps to lock in their memories and ensures they have the opportunity to provide their account of events while it’s still fresh.
4. Legal Protection: In some cases, the court may require a preservation deposition if there's concern that certain evidence or testimony may not be available when it’s time to present the case.

When Should You Use a Preservation Deposition?

Understanding the right time to utilize a preservation deposition can make all the difference in a case. Here are some common scenarios where you might want to consider using this tool:

• Witnesses in Distress: When a witness is dealing with a serious illness, injury, or is of advanced age, securing their testimony early on is a smart move. This ensures you can present their account in case they are unable to testify later.
• Witnesses in Another Jurisdiction: If a key witness is located in a different state or country and may not be available for trial, a preservation deposition can be a practical solution to preserve their testimony before travel logistics become an issue.
• Uncertain Availability: In cases where there’s uncertainty around a witness’s future availability (for example, military service or an unpredictable work schedule), you might want to use a preservation deposition to ensure you have their testimony in advance.

How Does a Preservation Deposition Work?

Like other depositions, a preservation deposition involves the formal questioning of a witness under oath. The process typically goes as follows:

• Notice: The party seeking the deposition will send a notice to all relevant parties to inform them of the intent to take a preservation deposition.
• Witnesses Are Sworn In: The witness is sworn in, as they would be in a traditional deposition, and the questioning begins.
• Recording: A preservation deposition is often recorded, either in writing or via video, so that the testimony can be reviewed at any point in the future.
• No Cross-Examination: In some cases, preservation depositions may occur without the usual back-and-forth questioning from both sides. The purpose is to preserve the testimony, not to engage in a full examination or challenge the witness’s credibility.

Preservation Deposition vs. Traditional Deposition

So, how does a preservation deposition compare to a traditional deposition? While both involve the recording of a witness’s testimony, the purposes differ significantly. A traditional deposition is used primarily as a tool for discovery or preparation for trial. Its goal is to gather information and evaluate the witness’s credibility for trial purposes. In contrast, a preservation deposition is a proactive measure, conducted with the goal of securing testimony for future use if the witness cannot appear in person.

Watch the video below for more on the different types of depositions:

Benefits of Preservation Depositions for Attorneys

As an attorney, there are several advantages to using preservation depositions in your legal strategy:

1. Peace of Mind: You won’t have to worry about the potential loss of important testimony. Having it preserved can alleviate anxiety over witness availability closer to trial.
2. Strengthening Your Case: A preservation deposition can help solidify your case by ensuring that important details aren’t lost due to unforeseen circumstances.
3. Flexibility in Trial Strategy: By recording testimony early, you have more flexibility in how you approach your trial. You can use the preserved testimony to influence your strategy, cross-examine other witnesses, or reinforce your arguments.

Conclusion

Incorporating preservation depositions into your legal toolkit is a smart and proactive approach to ensuring that important testimony doesn’t slip through the cracks. Whether you’re concerned about a witness’s availability or you simply want to strengthen your case, preservation depositions offer a valuable safety net. By recording the testimony of key individuals early, you give yourself the peace of mind that comes with knowing your evidence is locked in and secure.

Preservation Deposition FAQ

What is the purpose of a preservation deposition?

The main purpose of a preservation deposition is to capture and preserve the testimony of a witness who may not be available to testify in the future, ensuring that their testimony can still be used at trial.

How do preservation depositions differ from regular depositions?

While both types of depositions involve recording a witness’s testimony, preservation depositions are primarily used to secure testimony that may be unavailable in the future, whereas traditional depositions are typically used for discovery and case preparation.

Who can request a preservation deposition?

Any party involved in the case, typically the attorney representing the party concerned about the witness's availability, can request a preservation deposition.

Are preservation depositions allowed in all cases?

The use of preservation depositions depends on the circumstances of the case and the jurisdiction. In some cases, the court may approve or require a preservation deposition if there are concerns about witness availability.

‍