Meet and Confer: Essential Tips for Effective Disputes

The meet and confer process is a crucial step in resolving discovery disputes efficiently. Whether you're dealing with opposing counsel in a contentious case or trying to streamline discovery, mastering this process can save time, money, and stress. Here’s a comprehensive guide to help you navigate meet and confer sessions effectively.

Preparing for a Successful Meet and Confer

Preparation is key to a productive meet and confer. Here’s how to ensure you’re ready:

• Understand the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure (FRCP) – Make sure you're familiar with Rule 26(f) and other relevant rules governing discovery discussions.
• Review the discovery plan – Identify potential areas of dispute and clarify your client's priorities.
• Gather supporting documents – Have relevant materials ready to substantiate your position.
• Set an agenda – Outline discussion points to keep the meeting focused and efficient.
• Know your claims and defenses – Be prepared to explain how the requested discovery aligns with case strategy.

To further explain meet and confer, here's a crash course on the subject:

Building Relationships with Opposing Counsel

A strong professional relationship with opposing counsel can lead to a more productive meet and confer session. Keep these principles in mind:

• Engage, don’t just defend – Approach the conversation with a problem-solving mindset rather than a combative stance.
• Listen actively – Fully understand opposing counsel’s concerns to avoid misinterpretation.
• Discuss electronic discovery – Be proactive about preserving electronically stored information (ESI) and discuss obligations upfront.
• Show good faith – Courts expect a genuine effort to resolve disputes before seeking judicial intervention.
• Be mindful of resources – Negotiations should balance discovery needs with efficiency and cost-effectiveness.

Effective Negotiation Techniques for Discovery Disputes

The meet and confer process is essentially a negotiation. Use these strategies to improve outcomes:

• Offer a compromise – Come prepared with reasonable alternatives to overly broad or burdensome requests.
• Be specific – Vague objections and requests can lead to unnecessary conflict. Be precise about your concerns.
• Remain flexible – If opposing counsel presents a compelling argument, be open to adjusting your position.
• Practice active listening – Rephrase key points to confirm understanding and demonstrate engagement.
• Document discussions – Summarize agreements and disagreements in an email to prevent miscommunications.

Preserving Discoverable Information and Avoiding Pitfalls

Failing to preserve evidence can lead to serious consequences. Address these key points:

• Discuss preservation obligations – Clearly outline how each party will maintain discoverable information.
• Review legal hold notices – Ensure they are properly issued, updated, and followed.
• Avoid spoliation issues – Develop a plan to prevent accidental destruction or alteration of evidence.
• Clarify ESI expectations – Define the scope of electronic discovery early to prevent future disputes.
• Set clear discovery timelines – Agree on deadlines to ensure timely compliance and avoid unnecessary motion practice.

Resolving Impasses and Seeking Court Intervention

Sometimes, despite best efforts, discovery disputes can’t be resolved. Here’s what to do next:

• Recognize when to seek court intervention – If discussions reach a standstill, filing a motion may be necessary.
• Follow proper procedures – Courts often require proof that parties have engaged in good faith conferring efforts.
• Be prepared to justify your position – Judges expect a well-reasoned argument backed by case law and procedural rules.
• Understand potential consequences – Seeking intervention may result in court-imposed sanctions or additional costs.
• Know the judge’s expectations – Each judge may have unique preferences regarding discovery disputes, so review any relevant local rules or standing orders.

FAQ: Meet and Confer Process

1. What is a meet and confer?

A meet and confer is a required step in the legal process where parties attempt to resolve discovery disputes before seeking court intervention.

2. Is a meet and confer mandatory?

Yes, in most jurisdictions, attorneys must attempt to resolve discovery disputes through a meet and confer before filing a motion to compel.

3. How do I prepare for a meet and confer?

Review relevant rules, gather supporting documents, set an agenda, and understand your claims and defenses.

4. What happens if opposing counsel refuses to cooperate?

Document your efforts to resolve the issue and, if necessary, file a motion to compel with the court.

5. Can a meet and confer be conducted via email?

Yes, but in-person or phone discussions are often more effective. Some courts may require verbal communication before considering the meet and confer process complete.

6. How long does the meet and confer process take?

It depends on the complexity of the dispute. Some issues can be resolved in a single conversation, while others may require multiple discussions.

7. What should I do after a meet and confer?

Summarize the discussion in writing, noting any agreements or remaining disputes, and follow up as needed.

Mastering the meet and confer process can make a significant difference in the efficiency and outcome of your case. With preparation, collaboration, and strategic negotiation, you can resolve disputes effectively and keep litigation moving forward.

‍