How to File a Motion to Dismiss a Case

A motion to dismiss is a request to the court to dismiss a case due to defects in the plaintiff’s complaint. It serves as an early defense strategy, potentially ending litigation before it progresses to costly and time-consuming stages.

A defendant can file a motion to dismiss at the outset of the case, typically in response to the plaintiff’s complaint. However, once the defendant files an answer, they generally waive their right to file a motion to dismiss, making it essential to act promptly.

Watch the video below, "What is a Motion to Dismiss" for more information.

Reviewing the Plaintiff’s Complaint

Analyzing the Allegations and Claims

Carefully reviewing the plaintiff’s complaint is the first step in determining whether there are legal deficiencies that justify dismissal. Consider the following:

• Identify any legal insufficiencies or missing elements in the complaint.
• Use document management tools to annotate and organize relevant documents.
• Highlight weaknesses in the plaintiff’s claims that may form the basis for dismissal.

Grounds for Filing a Motion to Dismiss

Lack of Jurisdiction

Jurisdictional challenges can serve as strong grounds for dismissal. Common jurisdictional issues include:

• Lack of subject matter jurisdiction: The court does not have the legal authority to hear the case.
• Lack of personal jurisdiction: The court does not have authority over the defendant.
• Insufficient service of process: The plaintiff failed to properly serve the defendant with the complaint.

Failure to State a Claim

A motion to dismiss can also be filed if the complaint fails to meet the legal requirements for a valid claim. If the plaintiff does not sufficiently allege facts that support their legal claims, the case may be dismissed for failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted.

Preparing Your Motion to Dismiss

Compiling Necessary Research and Evidence

A successful motion to dismiss relies on thorough legal research and evidence. Consider these steps:

• Identify relevant statutes and case law that support your motion.
• Use legal research tools to find precedent that strengthens your arguments.
• Gather evidence demonstrating why the case should be dismissed.

Writing and Formatting Your Motion

Following Court Rules

Each jurisdiction has specific requirements for formatting and structuring motions. Adhere to the following general guidelines:

• Begin with a concise introduction stating the basis for the motion.
• Clearly outline the legal arguments supporting dismissal.
• Use straightforward, persuasive language to present your case.

Filing and Serving Your Motion to Dismiss

Submitting the Motion to the Court

Once the motion is drafted, follow the appropriate procedures for filing:

• Submit the motion according to the court’s filing rules.
• Serve a copy to the opposing party and any other required entities.
• Pay any necessary filing fees as required by the court.

Attending the Motion Hearing

Presenting Your Case

If a hearing is scheduled, be prepared to argue why the case should be dismissed:

• Present your arguments clearly and concisely.
• Anticipate and respond to the plaintiff’s counterarguments.
• Be ready to answer any questions from the judge.

Dealing with the Court’s Decision

Understanding the Ruling

After reviewing the motion, the court will issue a ruling:

• If granted, the case is dismissed, though the plaintiff may have the right to appeal.
• If granted with leave to amend, the plaintiff can revise and refile their complaint.
• If denied, the case proceeds to the next stage of litigation.

Next Steps

Proceeding with the Case or Appealing

• If the motion is granted, the defendant wins, and the case is dismissed.
• If denied, the case moves forward to discovery, summary judgment, or trial.
• The plaintiff may appeal the decision, requiring further legal strategy.

Conclusion

Filing a motion to dismiss requires meticulous preparation and a solid understanding of legal principles. By following these steps, attorneys can strengthen their case and potentially avoid prolonged litigation. Whether you’re a solo practitioner or part of a larger legal team, mastering this process is essential for effective litigation strategy.

Motion to Dismiss a Case FAQ

Can a motion to dismiss be filed at any time?

No. A motion to dismiss is typically filed at the beginning of a case in response to the plaintiff’s complaint. Once the defendant files an answer, they generally waive the right to file this motion.

What happens if a motion to dismiss is granted?

If the court grants the motion to dismiss, the case is either permanently dismissed or dismissed with leave to amend, allowing the plaintiff to correct deficiencies and refile the complaint.

Can a motion to dismiss be appealed?

Yes. If the court grants the motion, the plaintiff may appeal the decision. Likewise, if the motion is denied, the defendant may seek appellate review under certain circumstances.

What are the most common reasons for dismissing a case?

Common reasons include lack of jurisdiction, failure to state a claim, insufficient service of process, and other legal deficiencies in the plaintiff’s complaint.

Does filing a motion to dismiss delay the case?

Yes. While the motion is pending, case proceedings may be paused until the court rules on the motion. If denied, the case resumes as usual.

‍