Deposition Vs. Affidavit: Differences and Examples

Affidavits and depositions are fundamental tools in the legal process, each serving distinct purposes and requirements. An affidavit is a written statement sworn under oath, commonly used to present facts in a clear and concise manner. Depositions, on the other hand, involve sworn testimony given outside of court, often as part of the discovery process. Both are critical for verifying and preserving information, and understanding their differences, uses, and implications is essential for navigating legal proceedings effectively. This blog explores the nuances of affidavits and depositions, helping you determine which is best suited to your needs while providing insights into their procedures, costs, and importance in litigation.

Let's explore more of the differences between these two litigation tools.

What Is an Affidavit or Written Statement?

Affidavits or declarations under 22 CFR 92.22 are written statements taken under oath. An affiant must always take an oath under a person with authority to do so without any notice to any adverse parties.

In all cases, an affidavit must be notarized by a notary public. “Notarized” means that the facts in the affidavit have been verified under oath, the document signed, and a notary public has certified the document. A notary must witness your signature.

The body of the affidavit comprises the deponent's statements, which are clear and concise facts presented by the deponent to support the document's authenticity.

It is criminal to sign an affidavit containing false information. For this reason, it is essential to read the document carefully before signing it to ensure that it has accurate and true information. An affidavit must clarify any statements made by the affiant are opinions or beliefs.

What is a Deposition?

Under § 900.61, depositions are the sworn testimonies of a witness outside of court as part of discovery. Depositions may be used in court under certain circumstances. The term deponent refers to the person who is being deposed.

Affidavits serve as important sworn statements that verify facts relevant to various legal matters, highlighting the necessity of understanding the role of the deponent in this process.

Different jurisdictions have different deposition rules, also known as State Civil Procedure Rules. Depositions by oral questions are governed by Rule 30 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. While the written ones are governed by Rule 31 of the same Civil Procedure.

Let’s delve into the differences between these two types of depositions, oral and written:

Oral Depositions and Testimony

An oral deposition does not involve a court directly; each party initiates and supervises the process. The parties present at a deposition include the person making the sworn statement, also known as the deponent, attorneys for all interested parties, and a person qualified to administer oaths.

The stenographer may record a deposition, but electronic recording is becoming more common. All parties may question the witness during the deposition. Depositions are a deliberate process, so lawyers may not coach their clients’ testimony, and they may risk not objecting to questions in court.

Oral depositions are inadmissible at trial as they are hearsay. A deposition witness, however, is entitled to three exceptions to the hearsay rule.

1. When a party admits to something against their interests in a deposition.
2. When a witness contradicts their deposition during the trial.
3. Finally, the case of an unavailable witness at trial (Federal Rules of Evidence, Article VIII).

Written Depositions

Written questions may be used in depositions as well. Parties submit questions ahead of time in this kind of deposition and the deponent answers only those questions. In contrast to oral depositions, written depositions are less expensive since lawyers do not have to attend.

However, this method has the disadvantage that it is difficult to follow up on a witness's answers. Instead of depositions, in these cases parties most commonly use interrogatories.

Key Differences Between Affidavits and Depositions

Here is a table summarizing some of the differences we have highlighted between these two concept

Choosing Between an Affidavit and a Deposition

When deciding between an affidavit and a deposition, it’s essential to consider the specific needs of your case. An affidavit is a written statement made under oath, while a deposition is an oral testimony made under oath and transcribed. Here are some factors to consider:

• Written vs. Oral Testimony: If you need to provide a written statement, an affidavit is the better choice. However, if you prefer to provide a spoken testimony, a deposition is the way to go.
• Convenience: Affidavits are often more convenient, as they can be prepared and signed at any time. Depositions, on the other hand, require scheduling and may involve travel.
• Cost: Affidavits are generally less expensive than depositions, as they don’t require the presence of a court reporter or other officials.
• Flexibility: Depositions offer more flexibility, as they allow for questioning and cross-examination.

Ultimately, the choice between an affidavit and a deposition depends on the specific requirements of your case and your personal preferences.

Examples of Affidavits and When to Use Each

Courts, attorneys, and financial institutions create the majority of affidavit forms. An attorney prepares the affidavit form when they prepare court documents, wills, or powers of attorney on your behalf.

• Financial affidavit: Many courts require you to submit a financial affidavit when you are going through a divorce.
• Loan affidavit: For a loan application, the lender will provide the right affidavit forms.
• General affidavit: A spouse may need an affidavit to qualify for marital benefit when selling or verifying their marital status before selling the property. It is important to tailor such general affidavits to each case.
• Affidavits in court: It is common for witnesses to give oral testimony at a court trial. However, there may be situations when affidavits are used, such as when a witness cannot appear.
• Affidavit of a lost document: Often, an affidavit can re-establish the authenticity of a vital legal document that was lost or destroyed. For example, an affidavit and indemnity agreement may allow you to recover your funds in the case of a lost or a destroyed promissory note
• Affidavit of identity theft: You may need to provide an affidavit to prove identity theft to creditors, banks, and credit bureaus.

The Deposition Process

Deponents must be adequately notified before a deposition takes place. Local rules may vary, but five days' notice is usually sufficient. Non-parties to the lawsuit must be served with a subpoena (a court-approved summons).

Interrogatories and document production requests often precede depositions since evidence from those documents often informs questions posed to deponents. The court reporter attaches copies of any documents, photographs, or other evidence referred to during the deposition as exhibits to the transcript following the deposition.

Court reporters as well as notaries public generally lead the deponent through an oath before the deposition begins to ensure that the testimony will be accurate and true.

Purpose and examples of depositions

Depositions allow attorneys to learn what a witness knows about a case and preserve that witness's testimony in case of trial. Depositions and other discovery tools (such as obtaining documents and admitting specific facts) are expected in civil cases, which enable both sides to evaluate their arguments realistically.

Ideally, this information will help them settle the matter. But depositions in criminal cases serve different purposes. In most states, criminal depositions are only allowed if a judge concludes that a vital witness will be unable to provide testimony at trial.

Several states do not require judges' approval before deposing in criminal cases. In some states, criminal depositions are also called conditional examinations.

Consult your state's notary laws if you are unfamiliar with or have questions about affidavits, depositions, or other legal documents.

Civil Procedure Laws - Cornell Law School

State Notary Laws - National Notary

Federal Rules of Civil Procedure - U.S.C.

Importance of the Deponent’s Signature

The deponent’s signature is a crucial element of an affidavit. By signing the affidavit, the deponent is attesting to the truthfulness of the statements made and acknowledging that they are aware of the consequences of providing false information. The signature serves as a formal acknowledgment of the deponent’s responsibility for the accuracy of the information provided.

In addition to the deponent’s signature, the affidavit must also be notarized by a notary public. This adds an extra layer of authenticity to the document and ensures that the deponent’s signature is genuine.

Legal Consequences of a False Affidavit

Providing false information in an affidavit can have severe legal ramifications. If a deponent is found to have intentionally provided false information, they may be charged with perjury, a criminal offense that can result in fines, imprisonment, or both.

In addition to criminal charges, providing false information in an affidavit can also damage a person’s credibility and reputation. It can also lead to civil lawsuits and other legal issues.

Role of a Deponent

A deponent is a person who makes a sworn statement in an affidavit. The deponent’s role is to provide accurate and truthful information about a particular matter. The deponent must be of legal age and of sound mind to understand the impact of their statements.

The deponent must also have personal knowledge of the facts they are providing. They cannot provide information that they have heard from someone else or that is based on speculation.

Components of a Valid Affidavit

A valid affidavit must contain several key components, including:

• Title and Statement of Purpose: The title of the affidavit should clearly indicate its purpose and the matter to which it relates.
• Introductory Section: This section should provide personal information about the deponent, including their full name, age, occupation, and address.
• Body of the Affidavit: This section should contain the statements or facts that the deponent wishes to present.
• Statement of Truth: The deponent must declare that the information provided is accurate to the best of their knowledge.
• Signature and Jurat Section: The deponent’s signature and the notary public’s signature and seal are required to authenticate the affidavit.

FAQ: Deposition vs Affidavit – Differences and Applications

1. What is the primary difference between an affidavit and a deposition?
An affidavit is a written declaration made under oath and notarized, typically used to present facts concisely. A deposition, on the other hand, involves oral testimony given under oath, often recorded and transcribed, as part of the discovery process in legal cases.

2. When should I use an affidavit instead of a deposition?
An affidavit is best suited when you need to provide a written, sworn statement that does not require cross-examination. Affidavits are commonly used for financial disclosures, loan applications, and when witnesses cannot attend court.

3. Are depositions admissible in court?
Depositions are generally considered hearsay and are inadmissible at trial, except in certain cases such as:

• When a party admits something against their interest.
• When a witness contradicts their deposition during trial.
• When a witness is unavailable at trial (as per the Federal Rules of Evidence).

4. How do oral and written depositions differ?

• Oral Depositions: Conducted in the presence of attorneys, with the deponent answering questions directly. They allow for follow-up questions and cross-examination.
• Written Depositions: Consist of pre-submitted written questions that the deponent answers. These are less expensive but limit follow-up questioning.

5. What are the components of a valid affidavit?
A valid affidavit must include:

• Title and Statement of Purpose: Describing its intent.
• Introductory Section: Personal details of the deponent (name, age, occupation).
• Body: A factual account presented clearly and concisely.
• Statement of Truth: Declaration of the truthfulness of the statements.
• Signature and Jurat: Signatures of the deponent and a notary public, along with the notary seal.

6. Can providing false information in an affidavit lead to legal consequences?
Yes, signing a false affidavit is considered perjury, a criminal offense punishable by fines, imprisonment, or both. Additionally, it can harm credibility and result in civil lawsuits.

7. Who is responsible for paying deposition costs?
Typically, the party requesting the deposition covers the costs, including court reporter fees and transcription services. However, costs may be shared or reimbursed depending on agreements or court rulings.

8. What are some examples of affidavits?

• Financial Affidavit: For divorce or financial disclosures.
• Loan Affidavit: Required during loan applications.
• Affidavit of Lost Document: Used to re-establish authenticity of a lost document.
• Affidavit of Identity Theft: To report identity theft to banks or credit bureaus.
• General Affidavit: For purposes like marital status verification.

9. Why are depositions important in legal proceedings?
Depositions allow attorneys to learn what a witness knows and preserve their testimony for trial. They are part of discovery in civil cases and help both sides evaluate their arguments realistically.

10. What factors should I consider when choosing between an affidavit and a deposition?

• Testimony Format: Written (affidavit) vs. oral (deposition).
• Convenience: Affidavits are more convenient; depositions require scheduling.
• Cost: Affidavits are generally less expensive.
• Flexibility: Depositions offer cross-examination and follow-up opportunities.

‍