Deposition of Expert Witness | California Best Practices

When it comes to litigation in California, the deposition of expert witnesses is an essential part of the discovery phase that can significantly shape the direction of a case. Whether you're an attorney preparing for your first expert witness deposition or you're looking to refine your approach, understanding California's specific rules and best practices is crucial to ensuring a smooth, efficient process.

In this blog post, we’ll walk through the key elements of expert witness depositions in California, from the rules governing them to best practices that can help you manage costs and avoid common challenges.

Understanding Expert Witness Depositions in the California Code of Civil Procedure

In California civil procedure, expert witness depositions are governed by the California Code of Civil Procedure (CCP). These depositions are used to gather testimony from experts, allowing both parties to evaluate the strength of the opposing side’s expert opinions and strategies. Depositions are a vital part of discovery because they allow attorneys to prepare for trial by getting a preview of what expert testimony will look like.

It’s important to understand that expert witness depositions are not just about questioning the witness. They're a strategic tool that can influence your entire case—shaping decisions about settlement, trial tactics, and even case outcomes. So, as you prepare, remember that thorough preparation and knowledge of the procedural rules will make a huge difference.

Preparing for Expert Witness Depositions

To ensure a successful deposition of expert witness in California, preparation is key. Here are some best practices to follow:

1. Identify Expert Witnesses Early: The earlier you identify potential expert witnesses in the discovery phase, the better prepared you’ll be when it comes time to schedule depositions. This gives both you and your expert more time to review case materials and coordinate schedules.
2. Prepare the Expert: It’s crucial to ensure your expert is fully prepared for the deposition. They should be familiar with the case facts, potential questions, and expected challenges. The more your expert understands the scope of their deposition, the better they will perform when testifying.
3. Understand Fee Structures: Expert witnesses typically charge for their time, including preparation and the actual deposition. Be sure to understand the expert's fee structure, as outlined in California Code of Civil Procedure § 2034.470, and budget accordingly. Knowing what to expect in terms of costs, including negotiation and travel charges, will help you avoid surprises later.
4. Consider Retaining an Experienced Attorney: If you’re not experienced in handling expert witness depositions, it might be wise to retain an attorney with expertise in this area. They can help you navigate the complex legal landscape, ensure compliance with CCP regulations, and improve the effectiveness of your deposition strategy.

Serving a Deposition Notice in California Civil Procedure

In California, the deposition notice must meet certain requirements to be valid. Proper party noticing is crucial, as it ensures that the legal requirements for deposition notices are met, including the necessity to disclose any intention to record the testimony by audio or video. Strategic designation of witnesses, such as non-retained experts, is also essential for effectively utilizing deposition testimony during trial. Here’s a quick overview of what needs to be included:

1. Timing: You must serve the notice on the opposing party at least 10 business days before the deposition date. This ensures both sides have adequate time to prepare.
2. Details: The notice should clearly outline key information, such as the name and address of the expert, the date and time of the deposition, and the location. You’ll also need to specify the method of recording (audio or video) and any additional details about the deposition.
3. Proof of Service: Make sure you serve the notice properly, either electronically or via mail. It’s essential that you have proof of service to confirm that the opposing party received the notice.

Expert Witness Deposition Strategy

Developing an effective expert witness deposition strategy is crucial for successful litigation. The strategy should be tailored to the specific case and the expert witness involved. Start by thoroughly reviewing the expert’s report, deposition testimony, and any other relevant documents. This will help you identify potential weaknesses and areas to challenge.

When planning your questioning, include a mix of open-ended and leading questions to elicit the desired information. Consider the expert’s credibility, qualifications, and potential biases as you develop your strategy. A well-planned approach can help you effectively challenge the opposing party’s expert and strengthen your own case.

Be prepared to adapt your strategy during the deposition based on the expert’s responses and any unexpected developments. Effective communication with the expert witness and the retaining attorney is also essential to ensure a successful deposition. By staying flexible and well-prepared, you can navigate the complexities of expert witness depositions with confidence.

Managing Expert Witness Fees and Costs

One of the most common challenges in the deposition of expert witnesses is managing costs associated with the party's expert witness. Here are some tips for navigating this aspect:

1. Understand Fee Structures: Expert witnesses often charge hourly rates for both preparation time and the deposition itself. Make sure you fully understand the expert’s fee structure and negotiate the terms if possible.
2. Negotiate Fees: You don’t have to accept fees as they are presented. If the expert witness’s fees seem high, don’t hesitate to negotiate, especially if you can share budget constraints or other relevant information.
3. Cost-Sharing Strategies: In some cases, both parties may agree to share the costs of the expert deposition. This can be a useful strategy to reduce the financial burden on either side.
4. Monitor Costs: Keep an eye on any costs associated with the deposition, especially if the expert witness incurs fees for additional preparation time. It’s important to limit costs to what is necessary for the case.
5. Challenge Unreasonable Fees: If you believe the fees or costs are unreasonable, you have the right to challenge them. Make sure you are clear about what is considered reasonable in your jurisdiction.

Overcoming Common Challenges in Expert Witness Depositions

While expert witness depositions are essential to any case, there are several common challenges that may arise during the process. Here’s how to address them:

1. High Fees or Costs: Disputes over fees are common. If an expert’s rates seem too high, you can negotiate or challenge the fees in court if necessary.
2. Excessive Preparation Time: Experts may request more time than necessary for case preparation. Monitor the amount of time they’re spending and ensure it's reasonable.
3. No-Show Experts: An expert witness failing to show up for their deposition can throw a wrench in your plans. Always have a backup expert or an alternate deposition date in place, just in case.
4. Unclear Fee Structures: Avoid disputes by ensuring that the expert’s fee structure is clearly defined and understood by all parties involved from the outset.

Here's a quick video on what an expert video might be asked during a deposition:

Best Practices for a Successful Expert Witness Deposition

To make the most of your deposition of expert witness in California, follow these best practices:

1. Ensure Expert Preparedness: A well-prepared expert is key. They should be clear on what to expect during the deposition, how to answer questions, and the overall structure of the deposition.
2. Video Recording: If possible, consider video-recording the expert witness testimony. Video depositions are not only useful for reviewing the testimony later but can also serve as powerful evidence in trial.
3. Identify Experts Early: Know who your experts are and what they’ll contribute to your case. Don’t wait until the last minute to lock down witnesses.
4. Disclose Your Plans: If you intend to use video or audio technology for recording the deposition, make sure all parties are aware of this well in advance. This will avoid any surprises and potential objections down the line.
5. Keep Testimony Concise: Video depositions can be long, but you can make them more effective by editing out unnecessary parts—such as objections or side conversations—to focus on the substance of the testimony.

Best Practices for Expert Witness Testimony

To ensure effective expert witness testimony, thorough preparation is key. Expert witnesses should review all relevant documents and be ready to answer questions clearly and concisely. Attorneys should make sure their expert witnesses are aware of the deposition notice requirements and the code of civil procedure governing expert witness depositions.

Expert witnesses should avoid using technical jargon and complex terminology, making their testimony accessible and understandable. Additionally, they should be prepared for the potential use of electronically stored information as evidence. Treating physicians and other experts should be ready to provide detailed information about their treatment and opinions.

Understanding the discovery phase and the rules governing expert witness depositions is crucial. Expert witnesses should also be transparent about their preparation time, including the time spent reviewing documents and preparing their report. Attorneys should ensure their expert witnesses are aware that their testimony may be used as evidence in court. By following these best practices, expert witnesses can provide effective and reliable testimony that supports their case.

Conclusion

The deposition of expert witness in California is an essential part of any litigation strategy. Whether you’re seeking to assess the strength of your opponent’s expert testimony or preparing your own expert to testify, understanding the rules and best practices is critical. By following the steps outlined here, you’ll be well-equipped to navigate the complexities of expert witness depositions and use them effectively to support your case.

FAQ

What is the purpose of an expert witness deposition?

An expert witness deposition allows attorneys to gather information about an expert’s testimony before trial. It helps assess the strength of the expert's opinion and strategies while giving both parties insight into what the expert will testify to.

How much time in advance must I serve the deposition notice?

In California, the deposition notice must be served at least 10 business days before the scheduled deposition date.

What if the expert witness does not show up for the deposition?

If the expert witness does not attend their deposition, it can significantly delay the case. Make sure to have a backup plan in place, such as rescheduling the deposition or securing an alternative expert witness.

Can I challenge the fees charged by an expert witness?

Yes, if you feel the fees are unreasonable, you can challenge them in court. It's essential to understand what is considered a reasonable fee for expert witness services in your jurisdiction.

What should I do if my expert’s fees are too high?

If your expert's fees are too high, you can attempt to negotiate a lower rate or explore options to share costs with the opposing party. It's also possible to challenge excessive fees in court if necessary.

‍